Why Most Insurance Estimates Need to Be Supplemented: Key Insights

April 23, 2025

When dealing with roofing repairs or replacements, insurance estimates are often a starting point, not the final answer. While your insurance company will set the initial price based on their assessment, it's common for these estimates to fall short of covering the full cost of the repairs or replacement. This is why insurance estimates often need to be supplemented. In this article, we'll discuss why insurance estimates require supplementation and how to ensure your insurance claim fully covers the necessary work.

What Insurance Estimates Miss

The initial insurance estimate provided by your insurance company is generally based on a formula they use to assess the value of the damage. However, these estimates frequently miss certain line items that are crucial for completing the job correctly. For example, local codes, labor costs, dump fees, and overhead are often overlooked or underrepresented.


These omissions can leave you with an incomplete estimate that doesn’t reflect the true cost of repairs or replacement. In these cases, it’s necessary to supplement the insurance claim to include all the necessary line items that were initially excluded. Without supplementing, you could be left paying out-of-pocket for critical aspects of the job that the insurance estimate didn’t cover.

Why Supplementing Your Insurance Claim Is Essential

Supplementing your insurance claim is an essential part of the process. It involves reviewing the insurance estimate, identifying missing items, and submitting an updated claim that accurately reflects the full cost of repairs or replacement. This includes adding necessary line items such as local building codes, disposal fees, and other expenses that are often overlooked.


By supplementing your claim, you ensure that your roofing project is completed to the correct standards and in full compliance with your insurance company’s requirements. The goal is to have the final cost of repairs covered by your insurance policy, so you’re not left with unexpected expenses.


A reputable roofing contractor with experience in handling insurance claims can help guide you through this process. They can provide a detailed checklist of the items that should be included in an insurance estimate and assist you in identifying the missing pieces.

What You Should Know About the Supplementation Process

While supplementing your insurance claim is important, it can be a tricky process. Insurance companies might push back on certain claims, especially when it comes to costs like overhead or profit margins. It’s not uncommon for insurers to question additional charges or request further documentation to support your claim.


This is where a knowledgeable roofing contractor can be invaluable. With experience in working with insurance companies, they can help navigate these challenges, providing the necessary documentation and explanations to get the claim approved. They will also understand the nuances of what’s typically covered in an insurance estimate versus what’s actually required to complete the job correctly.

The Role of RCV Policies in Supplementing Claims

If your roofing policy is based on an Actual Cash Value (ACV) or Replacement Cost Value (RCV), the supplementing process can vary. With an RCV policy, your insurance company is obligated to pay for everything necessary to complete the job properly. This includes all labor, materials, and other associated costs, ensuring that the roofing project is done correctly and the contractor is able to make a reasonable profit.


In cases where you have an RCV policy, supplementing the claim is even more critical. You should not have to pay for line items that are necessary to complete the job. If your claim is underfunded, it’s your right to supplement the insurance estimate to ensure the total cost of the project is covered.

How to Ensure Your Claim Is Fully Supplemented

To successfully supplement your claim, it’s essential to do your due diligence. This means working closely with a contractor who understands the insurance claim process. Contractors with experience in insurance claims can guide you through the process, helping you identify missing line items and assisting you in submitting the corrected claim to your insurance company.


At Right Hand Man, we provide our clients with a comprehensive checklist that outlines all the line items an insurance estimate should include. This gives our customers the power to go through the claim, add missing items, and send it back to their insurance company for approval.

Supplementing your insurance estimate is a crucial step in ensuring your roofing project is fully covered. While it may seem like an extra hassle, it’s necessary to get every cost accounted for, from labor to overhead to local building codes. If you’re unsure about how to supplement your claim, don’t hesitate to reach out to a roofing contractor with experience in insurance claims. Contact Right Hand Man today, and let us help you navigate the process and ensure that your roof replacement or repair is fully covered by your insurance policy.

April 23, 2025
When it comes to choosing the right roofing material for your home, asphalt shingles are one of the most popular and widely used options. With their affordability, durability, and versatility, asphalt shingles come in several varieties to suit different needs and preferences. Among these options, the three most common types of asphalt shingles are three-tab shingles, architectural shingles, and luxury shingles. Understanding the differences between these types will help you make an informed decision for your home. In this article, we’ll dive into each type of asphalt shingle and highlight their unique features and benefits.
April 23, 2025
When a strong storm hits, the last thing you want to worry about is whether your roof has suffered damage. Storm damage can sometimes be subtle, making it difficult to assess from the ground. However, catching roof damage early is crucial, as it can prevent further complications and ensure that your insurance claim is filed in time. The good news is that you don’t need to wait for a roofing professional to inspect your roof right away. With our free storm damage checklist, you can quickly determine whether your roof has been affected, giving you the information you need to move forward.
April 23, 2025
When dealing with roof damage, many homeowners are eager to get their insurance claims approved so quickly so they can move forward with repairs. However, it's important to understand that no matter how certain you are that your roof has significant damage, insurance adjusters have the final say on whether your claim is approved. While roofing contractors can provide a thorough inspection and even advocate on your behalf, only the insurance adjuster has the authority to officially approve or deny your claim. In this article, we'll explore the role of insurance adjusters , why you must rely on their decision for claim approval, and what steps you can take to ensure the process works in your favor.
A tree has fallen on the roof of a house.
April 23, 2025
After a storm hits, it's not uncommon for roofing companies to show up in neighborhoods, knocking on doors and offering their services. While some companies are reputable and genuinely want to help, others may try to lock you into a contract before your roof damage claim has even been approved. They'll encourage you to sign paperwork, giving them the right to handle your roof repairs without fully assessing the damage or understanding your insurance coverage. This type of pressure tactic is a red flag . It indicates that the roofing company might not have your best interests in mind. In this article, we'll explore why you should never sign any paperwork until your roof damage claim is approved, and we'll provide tips on navigating the roof damage insurance process safely and effectively.
April 21, 2025
When it comes to repairing or replacing your roof after damage, one of the first things you need to do is review your policy . Not only will this tell you what’s covered, but it will also help you understand if your insurance will fully pay for a new roof. The type of insurance policy you have can make a big difference in the amount your insurance company will pay out. There are two primary types of policies— Actual Cash Value (ACV) and Replacement Cost Value (RCV) —and understanding each will help you plan accordingly.  In this article, we’ll explore how each policy works, what you can expect from your insurance company, and how reviewing your policy can prevent surprises when you need a roof replacement.
April 21, 2025
When dealing with a roofing insurance claim, many homeowners find themselves confused about the payment process—especially when it comes to paying the deductible. While navigating the claims process can be complicated, one thing is clear: you must pay your deductible once your claim is approved . Unfortunately, some roofing companies offer to cover your deductible to make their services seem more appealing. But this practice is not only misleading—it's also illegal.  In this article, we’ll break down why paying your deductible is essential, how to spot roofing companies that offer illegal deals, and what you should do when your insurance claim is approved.
April 21, 2025
The roofing industry is no stranger to insurance claims. These claims, while necessary, often bring out the worst in the industry due to the complexities involved, delays, and disagreements between contractors, clients, and insurance companies. Navigating these claims can be a daunting process, but it’s crucial for both contractors and homeowners to understand the challenges and the impact they can have. In this article, we will explore the common issues surrounding roofing industry insurance claims, why they often result in disputes, and how roofing companies and homeowners can work together to ensure a smoother process.
More Posts